Training has been part of the human society from the very beginning. Permitting the state to dictate the requirements and procedures of Christian education jeopardizes the flexibility of parents and church members to exercise their educational prerogative, to carry out their responsibility to God for the schooling of their youngsters.
However, there’s one other consequence of this institutional housing of the overwhelming majority of philosophers of schooling that is worth noting—one that is not present in a comparable method in philosophers of science, for example, who virtually at all times are located in departments of philosophy—namely, that have as a trainer, or in some other schooling-related function, is a qualification to change into a thinker of education that in lots of instances is valued not less than as a lot as depth of philosophical training.
Over time, as they moved up the tutorial ladder it would change into apparent that some had reached the limit imposed upon them by nature, and they’d be directed off into applicable social roles by which they’d find achievement, for his or her abilities would match the calls for of these roles.
In assessing this decision—as in fact philosophers have incessantly executed (see, for example, Kymlicka 1995)—a stability has to be achieved between (i) the curiosity of civic society in having an informed, effectively-educated, participatory citizenry; (ii) the interest of the Amish as a group in preserving their very own tradition; and (iii) the pursuits of the Amish youngsters, who (in response to some no less than) have a right to become autonomous people who could make reflective selections for themselves concerning the nature of the life they wish to lead.
However, some works in this style are among the classics of educational thought”—a extra felicitous label than philosophy of education”; circumstances in point would be the essays, pamphlets and letters of Thomas Arnold (headmaster of Rugby faculty), John Wesley (the founding father of Methodism), J.H. (Cardinal) Newman, T.H. Huxley, and the writings on progressive education by A.S. Neill (of Summerhill college).